San Diego Union-Tribune
Source: Wayback availability API
A decade ago, the city agreed to spend $30 million to put cameras in streetlights.
They were cutting-edge, with sensors that took images and turned them into data. The grand idea was to make San Diego the world’s largest smart-city platform, a system to inform residents of traffic patterns and available parking. It wasn’t a policing thing. The city’s Sustainability Department pitched it.
It took well more than a year for police to realize that 3,000 so-called Smart Streetlights across the city housed cameras. In 2018, they started tapping them to solve crimes, notably a deadly shooting at an Otay Mesa Church’s Chicken. The cameras even provided footage of a sheriff’s jail deputy fatally shooting a fleeing man, images that would later be used to convict the deputy.
But police use of cameras brought public cries of privacy breaches. Were they surveilling people? Who had access to the cameras? Advocates for privacy and civil rights banded together with technology experts, and the battle was on. By late summer 2020, the entire camera system went dark.
Fast-forward to today, San Diego has found itself in precisely the same scenario. Last week, the City Council voted to shut down an entirely new smart surveillance system, citing many of the same concerns raised several years earlier.
The latest iteration was only 500 surveillance cameras on streetlights across the city, but the cameras were coupled with Flock automated license plate readers, or ALPRs, a powerful AI tool that creates a searchable database of all vehicles in view.
The public outcry was bigger this time, citing fears of government overreach — particularly amid the Trump administration’s immigration crackdown — and public mistrust of police use of the technology.
San Diego police use of Flock came to an end Monday with a 7-0 City Council vote, with two absent.
“It was overwhelming relief,” said Homayra Yusufi of Partnership for the Advancement of New Americans, or PANA, which works with new immigrants and refugees. “To just know how harmful these cameras are, the risk that it poses to all San Diegans and, particularly through the work that I do for immigrant communities, the fear that it incited.”
Yusufi is a core member of the TRUST SD Coalition, a consortium of civil rights organizations, immigrant rights groups and privacy advocates. Born in the first battle against citywide cameras, the coalition was key to bringing down the surveillance tech both then and now. The cameras, she said, “never should have gone up in the first place.”
The local effort was boosted by a growing nationwide chorus of voices decrying ALPRs, particularly those from Flock.
“We started to find more and more people growing deeply concerned that, hey, this is not just like my video camera that I get for outside my garage. This is a national data-sharing network,” said UC San Diego professor Lilly Irani, who has a doctorate in information and computer science. She, too, is a member of TRUST.
Before casting his vote Monday, Councilmember Sean Elo-Rivera noted that some of the most “persistent voices” against ALPRs were from “young people who are the people most fluent in technology and who are often the most skeptical of it. That skepticism is not based on an irrational fear. It’s a rational fear that comes from understanding exactly what these tools can do.”
With Monday’s vote, San Diego appears to have become the largest city in the country to shut off its mounted network of license plate readers.
What now?
By noon Tuesday, all San Diego police officers had lost access to the systems, save for two administrators working on the wind-down. The city is also working with Flock to get the data erased. Anything that had already been impounded as evidence remains as evidence. Anything not already downloaded before access was cut off will be deleted.
On Friday, Flock confirmed it had “deactivated and disconnected” the services it had provided to San Diego.
A police spokesperson said Ubicquia, which provided the camera hardware, will remove all the cameras at no cost to the city, a roughly seven-week process expected to begin Dec. 7.
The day after the City Council vote, a Flock spokesperson said the company respected the city’s decision. It went on to say that San Diego police “solved countless crimes and made a measurable public safety impact with Flock technology. When a tool that is actively helping solve violent crimes is removed, public safety moves backward.
“That has real consequences: cases will take longer to solve, organized retail theft crews will operate with fewer obstacles, a missing child may not be returned home, and victims may wait longer, or indefinitely, for justice,” the statement read.
The department declined a request to interview Police Chief Scott Wahl, who wanted to keep the cameras. Last month, after the city’s Budget Committee unanimously voted to rescind permission for police to use ALPRs, Wahl said in a statement that removing cameras would make it harder for officers to solve crimes.
“We don’t have to guess whether ALPR helps solve crimes. We’ve seen it work in more than 900 cases, from stolen vehicles and kidnappings to murders,” he said.
A high-tech pilot program
Remember red-light cameras? Those issued at least 196,000 tickets between 1998 and 2013, before the city let the contract end and turned them off, joining a list of other Southern California cities. The cameras were unpopular, tourists were getting hit with nearly $500 citations, and it took four police officers to go through the photos. The cost savings for the city were a wash.
Not long after, though, San Diego agreed to be the first city to pilot CityIQ, which General Electric was calling an “intelligent cities platform.” The City Council approved the $30 million project in late 2016.
Some 3,000 Smart Streetlights would track movements of cars and people, particularly in busy urban areas. Developers could take the data — it would be publicly available — to make apps with real-time information about, say, open parking spots along downtown streets. One 2017 press release proclaimed “America’s Finest City is also becoming its smartest.”
San Diego police found out about the cameras in mid-2018. The following year, civil rights advocates learned police were accessing them and pushed back, concerned about the potential for unfettered access with little oversight. “We started to dig in,” Yusufi said, “and realized ‘Oh wow, these are really dangerous’ really fast.”
Then-Mayor Kevin Faulconer ordered the cameras shut off until the city could write rules governing their access and use. The Transparent and Responsible Use of Surveillance Technology — or TRUST — ordinance, named for the coalition that fought for it, followed. The City Council also created the Privacy Advisory Board to review all police surveillance technology — from drones to body-worn cameras to fingerprint scanners — with an eye toward civil liberties.
Many of those cameras San Diego installed a decade ago are dormant but still up. It was deemed too expensive to take them down.
Take two
In 2023, the Police Department returned with a bid to bring back 500 cameras coupled with something new: license plate readers tied to a searchable database that logged every vehicle in view. It would cost $3.5 million to install and another $2 million a year to run. The Privacy Advisory Board advised against the plan. The council approved it anyway.
“We are where we are because the city refused to take the advice of the Privacy Advisory Board that we created, that we appointed experts to, and we bragged about as a gold standard,” Elo-Rivera said at Monday’s meeting. “Rather than listen, we moved fast, and we broke things.”
Given San Diego’s strict new TRUST ordinance, police agreed to keep the city’s ALPR data on a metaphorical island — no outside agencies would have direct access.
But black eyes followed. In the first three weeks that San Diego used its license plate reader system, its data was unknowingly available for other California agencies — and nearly 13,000 searches from outside the department happened. Police apologized. It had been unintentional; the wrong switch was toggled on. In 2024, police intentionally shared data several times with federal agencies, but said the cases were not immigration-related.
Last December, news broke that the San Diego police captain who’d secured the Flock contract had retired and gone to work for Flock. That same month, the City Council reviewed the readers and cameras as required annually under the TRUST ordinance. It voted 5-3 to keep the tech.
Earlier this year, a man sued the city, alleging he was wrongfully jailed for a month after San Diego police using ALPRs targeted the wrong vehicle. And a few months ago, a group that advocates for refugees and displaced people sued the city, alleging the cameras and the database are an invasion of privacy.
Those legal battles were brewing as controversy surrounding Flock and concern over reported police misuse of its data in other cities made headlines nationwide.
A final blow came days before Monday’s City Council vote, when Councilmember Raul Campillo pulled his support for ALPRs after learning that San Diego police had used them to check the location of a domestic violence victim during an internal affairs investigation into a police officer. He alleged that was a misuse of the system, although police disagreed.
The council vote to shut off Flock’s automated license plate readers was unanimous, with two absent. By then, with several council members already having publicly signaled their desire to break with Flock, the vote itself was a touch anticlimactic.
More of a surprise was the 5-2 vote to also ditch the streetlight cameras, given the primary public focus was specific to ALPRs. Without Flock, the cameras were just cameras, and the footage was not being run through a database. The two votes to keep them rolling included Councilmember Vivian Moreno, who cited the solved Church’s Chicken murder case: “To me, the benefits of the streetlight cameras in solving crimes is undeniable.”
The decision to lose the simple cameras was not such a surprise to Irani. “It’s still a centralized camera system,” she said. “It’s run by a third party. It can be subpoenaed by the Trump administration.”
While the battle over Flock appears over, at least for now, in San Diego, there are still several cities around the region with ALPR cameras capturing images for a searchable database. Unlike San Diego’s self-imposed restriction from sharing, most local cities allow other California agencies to access the database, which is permissible under state law.
TRUST SD members said they stand ready to help if needed in regional fights, but they remained focused on San Diego. They are keenly aware that police want to start using drones as first responders, launching the unmanned aircraft from rooftops so they arrive at a scene even before officers do.
Perhaps the next local battlefront against surveillance.

